32 Comments
User's avatar
Jeff Silverman's avatar

Such an interesting background on the perceptions of the French on the potato, something I never knew existed (the negative perceptions), the potato advocacy that was needed albeit not successful until after thd 1789 Revolution. Thank you Jamie!! Thank you for this French Potato History!!

Expand full comment
Jamie Schler's avatar

Jeffrey, it makes me soooooo happy to know you read my stuff and enjoy it! It really does!

Expand full comment
Jeff Silverman's avatar

Jamie, I love your stuff!!

Expand full comment
Jamie Schler's avatar

XOXOXOX

Expand full comment
Kathy Roah's avatar

I will definitely try making this, but I especially LOVED reading the history of the potato. Your rendition was very entertaining.

Expand full comment
Jamie Schler's avatar

Thanks for saying that! I thought it was all fun stuff but was afraid I would be the only one who would think it was entertaining so yay!!! And please let me know when you make it!

Expand full comment
Dawn Fels's avatar

Have always loved your recipes. The stories and background that accompany them are refreshing given today’s sad goings-on. Thank you!

Expand full comment
Jamie Schler's avatar

Thank you so much, Dawn! I guess we all do what we can to help, right?

Expand full comment
Mao Zhou's avatar

Jamie, the extensive history that you share is absolutely fascinating. I haven’t even made it to the recipe yet.

Expand full comment
Jamie Schler's avatar

And this is only part one! Thank you so much, Mao Zhou!

Expand full comment
Mao Zhou's avatar

You’re probably familiar with “Potato Total” by Stefan Ekengren.

Expand full comment
Jamie Schler's avatar

No I am not!!

Expand full comment
Mao Zhou's avatar

The Roast smashed potatoes tossed with Olive tapenade are delicious.

Expand full comment
Tomas's avatar

Super article.

Expand full comment
Jamie Schler's avatar

Thanks!

Expand full comment
Tony Lupton's avatar

It's (sort of) a very fancy chip buttie. I love it.

Expand full comment
Jamie Schler's avatar

hahaha now I have to see what a chip buttie is!

Expand full comment
KathyGori's avatar

Well, this just looks amazing Jamie! Especially so as I stare out my rain streaked windows into the dark clouds. I need to bring this dish into my life...like soon!!!

Expand full comment
Jamie Schler's avatar

I can’t wait until you make it Kathy! Though I’m nervous since yours will be so much prettier than mine haha!!

Expand full comment
KathyGori's avatar

well, not so sure about the beauty part…but I think our French friends will love it

Expand full comment
Spencer Pierre LeGate's avatar

I lived for some years in a village just outside of Orleans back in the 1970's. Many of my friends and acquaintances stored a large sack of potatoes in a corner of their mudroom. Few meals I recall did not have some concoction of that tuber on the menu. I started a vegetable garden, even grew sweet corn. But my most reliable, and delicious , plant was the humble potato. The French varieties are exquisite. Many thanks for this article.

Expand full comment
Jamie Schler's avatar

Thank you for sharing this with us! As I was writing this, I kept thinking of my father-in-law's potager and those of his neighbors. They all grow potatoes.

Expand full comment
Lisa McLean's avatar

This looks luxuriously decadent deliciousness.

Expand full comment
Jamie Schler's avatar

Thank you, Lisa! Yeah... puff pastry, cream, potatoes...oddly both decadently luxurious and rustically simple at the same time!

Expand full comment
Writer Pilgrim by So Elite's avatar

OMG this looks divine... potato and puff pastry! Dreams are made of carbs.

Expand full comment
Jamie Schler's avatar

Oh, yeah, baby, they are!!

Expand full comment
Gundy Walton's avatar

All hail, the potato! Everything potato! Anything potato! Every day! All the time!

Being Northern European… what else? No day goes by without the Big P making an appearance in some glorious form.

The marriage of potato and puff pastry is almost too much to take in. I’ll have to try this - but may end up creating my own version of this recipe.

Expand full comment
Jamie Schler's avatar

Oh, Gundy! You come back and share your version of this recipe when you make it! 🙏

Expand full comment
Lisa McLean's avatar

Wow Jamie, what is not to love about finely sliced rounds of potato, lovingly encased in pastry then bathed in cream and baked until golden brown.

Expand full comment
Joel Rosenfeld's avatar

Thank you. I haven't learned that much about the potato since my Grandmother gave me her secret recipe for her latkes. (Potato pancakes)

Expand full comment
Cooking with Micheline's avatar

Very interesting reading I learned more about Parmentier. I had the chance to hold in my hand Parmentier book and read little parts as I consulted old cookbooks for my research of history of Quebec cooking some years ago. His book belongs to a collection of old cookbooks of à Montréal library. At the beginning of your text did you mean Iceland I am surprised Ireland is not mention? Is there a reason the cream is added after 30 minutes of cooking would it be possible to ad it before covering with top dough?

Expand full comment
Jamie Schler's avatar

I thought a lot about the cream and personally I think those 30 minutes might allow the pastry to set…I feared adding the cream at the beginning would make a soggy crust. But it is worth trying because this way was hard. I need to try it different ways.

Expand full comment