36 Comments
User's avatar
Susan Still's avatar

Yummy. Might make one of these for Thanksgiving, as my youngest & granddaughter do not like pumpkin pie. I was going to ask my youngest to make an apple pie, but these sound much better. Thanks, Jamie.

Expand full comment
Jamie Schler's avatar

It’s perfect for thanksgiving! Let me know if you make one of them!

Expand full comment
Doug G's avatar

I will make one instead of an apple pie. Thank you!

Expand full comment
Susan Still's avatar

I will.

Expand full comment
Bill Smitrovich's avatar

Jamie Do you ship to the states ? lol. I want to be shipped! Delishness

Expand full comment
Jamie Schler's avatar

Haha I’d personally deliver cake to you if I could! 😘

Expand full comment
Bill Smitrovich's avatar

How delish that would be !!!

Expand full comment
Bill Smitrovich's avatar

I’ll grind the beans myself !! Have a delicious day sweet Jamie

Expand full comment
Jamie Schler's avatar

xoxo

Expand full comment
Jamie Schler's avatar

You just need to make the coffee!

Expand full comment
Bill Smitrovich's avatar

How do you like it ?

Expand full comment
Jamie Schler's avatar

Fairly strong then with hot milk and a bit of sugar lol xx

Expand full comment
Bill Smitrovich's avatar

Do you have an online Skype cooking classes ? XO

Expand full comment
Jamie Schler's avatar

Ooooh no I don’t! Maybe in the future after the hotel!

Expand full comment
Bill Smitrovich's avatar

😎😘🌺🎼

Expand full comment
Bill Smitrovich's avatar

I am so impressed with your knowledge, commitment and artistry You should have an online baking show Would love to meet you in person someday But for now I enjoy the mixing and your posts and of course, you're so cute lol

Expand full comment
Jamie Schler's avatar

You are so adorable , Bill 🥰

Expand full comment
Bill Smitrovich's avatar

Oh.....go on..(-;}

Expand full comment
Jamie Schler's avatar

☺️

Expand full comment
Joe Zahner's avatar

Wonderful! We love apple cake. Lots of different apples in Minnesota. In fact we are making apple cake today for a birthday. Oh and also making caramel sauce to go with it. Love your Substack.

Expand full comment
Jamie Schler's avatar

Thank you!!! I’m so happy you read and enjoy my Substack!! And you must make both cakes!!

Expand full comment
Kimberly Montgomery (CA)'s avatar

Jamie, I made the cake without sugar using Granny Smith homemade applesauce instead 1 cup instead of 3/4. It looked beautiful and tasted fabulous to me since anything sweet is awful in my mouth after chemotherapy in 2008.

My sweetheart said it was good, but he missed the sugar. He said, having a side of Caramel sauce for those who enjoy sweeter desserts would be good.

Expand full comment
Jamie Schler's avatar

Kimberly, I’m so happy you made the cake and thank you so much for leaving this comment letting me and my readers know about your change and that it worked! I do like the idea of serving a sweet sauce on the side for those who like it sweeter! I do have a great recipe for caramel sauce in one of my posts!

Expand full comment
Steel Swift's avatar

Ok! Thanks so much for this recipe!

Expand full comment
Jamie Schler's avatar

Thank YOU! I Hope you’ll make it - and let me know!

Expand full comment
Steel Swift's avatar

I made it and it was great. One could use any season fruit - peaches come to mind!

Expand full comment
Ted Alby's avatar

Thank you Jamie.

I worked extensively with apple growers at one time and even had more than 100 trees of my own for plant disease research purposes. I never knew this history. Never thought once about the Italian "mela" for apple.

Once again, you've filled in a lot of fun background along with providing a wonderful sounding recipe. Sounds like a good cold winter day project.

Expand full comment
Jamie Schler's avatar

Thomas, as usual, I’m always thrilled that you read AND enjoy my posts! I really am! Thank you for always taking the time to comment too 💜 I hope your Thanksgiving holiday was wonderful!

Expand full comment
Ted Alby's avatar

Thank you Jaime. Our Thanksgiving was a week early because our daughter had to work Thanksguving day and immediately afterward fly out of town, but it was fabulous. I appreciate your posts. I learn a lot in addition to getting some nice recipes.

Expand full comment
Doug G's avatar

I made the French Apple Cake -- delicious! Moist and tender, with wonderful flavor, not overly sweet -- just right, in fact, served with a scoop of vanilla ice cream. I used a 3" high by 9" round spring form pan which worked well (anything lower would have been a disaster.) One thing I'd suggest is to quantify the apples (Rubinette, in my case) in terms of either weight or volume, as "6 apples" is a bit vague. I chose what I'd call an average apple size, perhaps 3" diameter, and the layers ended up being several slices tall, nearly to the top of the pan. Lovely, though -- thank you!

Expand full comment
Jamie Schler's avatar

Thanks for this comment, Doug! I agree about the apples - I struggle with this every time… for all fruits and vegetables. If I don’t it’s because I get lazy 🤦🏻‍♀️ I’m super thrilled you made and loved the cake. It’s a favorite. What I really love about French home baking is that it’s rarely oversweet or oversweetened.

Expand full comment
Doug G's avatar

Regarding the Latin word malum, you may be interested to know that apples and crabapples belong to the genus Malus.

Expand full comment
Doug G's avatar

Regarding the Latin word malum, you may be interested to know that apples and crabapples belong to the genus Malus.

Expand full comment
DerpDerpDerp's avatar

Minimize cake in your life, which is nothing but empty calories.

If you want Apples and something French, gallette is the way to go.

https://sallysbakingaddiction.com/salted-caramel-apple-galette/

Expand full comment
Kimberly Montgomery (CA)'s avatar

I learned so much about apples!

The cakes look amazing. I might just give baking a try. 😊

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Oct 21, 2023
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Jamie Schler's avatar

I know, right!?!

Expand full comment